NEWAI content checker: see which pages read like AI text

Knowledge baseAI search

Answer engine optimization (AEO)

Answer engine optimization (AEO) is the work of getting a site named and linked as a source in the answers AI tools give: Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot. For Google's own AI features, Google simply calls it SEO. The new part is that ChatGPT and Copilot find their sources through other search engines. Your rankings show none of it, so you measure it yourself, per AI and per question.

Updated Nov 20, 202612 min read

Is answer engine optimization different from SEO?

For Google, no. Google's guide to optimizing your website for generative AI features says it in one line: "From Google Search's perspective, optimizing for generative AI search is optimizing for the search experience, and thus still SEO." A page has to be indexed and eligible to show with a snippet.

For most of the work, AEO is SEO with a new name. The page still has to be good, findable and worth quoting. What's new is that you can't see it in your rankings anymore, so you have to measure it in a different way.

Outside Google, things do change. ChatGPT sometimes runs its searches through outside search providers, Microsoft among them. Its own crawler for search is OAI-SearchBot. Copilot sends its generated queries to Bing. The Gemini app draws on Google's index, but a separate control decides whether your site can appear in it. A rank tracker checks where a page sits in Google's results, and it never sees whether ChatGPT named your client.

You'll also hear GEO (generative engine optimization) and "AI SEO". They name the same work, and Google's guide treats AEO and GEO in one breath. ChatGPT counts as an answer engine whenever it searches the web and cites pages, and that's the part AEO is about.

How do AI answers pick their sources?

An AI answer starts as a handful of searches: the AI turns the question into several queries, pulls pages from a search index, writes its answer and cites some of the pages it read.

Google calls this query fan-out. In its own example, "how to fix a lawn that's full of weeds" also goes out as "best herbicides for lawns", "remove weeds without chemicals" and "how to prevent weeds in lawn". For AI Overviews and AI Mode the pages come from Google's Search index, picked by the same core ranking systems that run normal search. The other AIs do the same thing with a different index behind them, and a different bot that lets your page in:

AIWhere its sources come fromWhat lets a site inWhere you can see it
AI Overviews and AI ModeGoogle's Search index, through query fan-outGooglebot; indexed with a snippet; Search generative AI on include in Search ConsoleSearch Console's Generative AI report (impressions and pages); clicks sit in the Performance report under Web
Gemini appGoogle's Search index, through groundingGoogle-Extended allowedNo report from Google; visits from gemini.google.com in GA4
ChatGPTOutside search providers and OpenAI's own crawlerOAI-SearchBot allowed in robots.txt and in the firewallNo report from OpenAI; visits from chatgpt.com in GA4
CopilotBing's indexBeing in Bing's indexBing Webmaster Tools, AI Performance: citations only
PerplexityIts own searchPerplexityBot allowedNo report; visits from perplexity.ai in GA4

Two rows have a catch. Google-Extended has no effect on whether a site appears in Google Search. It only decides about training and about grounding in the Gemini app, and even then not every Gemini answer shows its sources. For ChatGPT, a site that blocks OAI-SearchBot won't be shown in its search answers, apart from plain navigational links. GPTBot is OpenAI's training crawler and a separate choice.

The page that gets cited is usually the one that answers the question. When ChatGPT and Gemini cited one of the sites in my account, it was the homepage 9 times out of 38. The others went to category pages, product pages, project pages and how-to guides. Similarweb saw the same in the US, on about 600,000 citations in ChatGPT and Google's AI Mode: AI rarely cites homepages.

Businesses got a treatment of their own in ChatGPT's answers. When it named one, it often linked a Google Maps search for the business name instead of the website. Of the 564 source links in ChatGPT's answers for the sites in my account, 227 (40%) were Maps searches. ChatGPT named a business without linking its site 8 times, and 7 of those linked a Maps search instead. Gemini cited no Maps links at all. So a name in an answer doesn't have to bring a visit, and the business name and its listings have to be right.

Two AI answers to the question which SEO agency is best for local businesses. ChatGPT names the agency, but all five of its sources are Google Maps searches; Gemini cites the agency's local SEO page as source 2

Demo account, sample data.

Does ranking in Google get you cited by ChatGPT and Gemini?

It helps for Google's own AI Overviews and much less for ChatGPT and Gemini. A page at the top of Google can be missing from the AI answer to the very same question.

In a study published in March 2026, Ahrefs looked at 863,000 keyword results and found that 37.9% of the URLs cited in AI Overviews also ranked in the top 10.

ChatGPT and Gemini stray much further from Google. In Ahrefs' study of 15,000 prompts from 2025, only 12% of the links cited by ChatGPT, Gemini or Copilot appeared in Google's top 10 for the same prompt. Both Ahrefs studies come from its own AI tracking data, which it sells.

Part of the reason is that the AI doesn't search what you typed. In a preprint from October 2026, not yet peer reviewed, ChatGPT rewrote the question in almost every run, and its two newest instant models never once searched the exact question. Google's first five result pages held only 6.4% to 9.4% of the URLs ChatGPT cited.

One site in my account shows how wide the gap can be. A Dutch site about legal costs ranks at an average position of 2.1 in Google for "legitieme portie berekenen", calculating the statutory share of an inheritance: 190 clicks from 1,825 impressions in the 90 days to 16 November 2026. On 16 November both AIs answered that same question. Each cited four other pages, from the Consumentenbond and from notary and inheritance-law sites, and neither of them named the site or linked to it.

A Dutch packaging-materials webshop at position 5.8 for "verpakkingsmaterialen" (packaging materials) did no better. ChatGPT named eight suppliers, every one with a Google Maps link, and the shop wasn't in either answer.

Two sites don't give you odds, and they don't have to. They show that a good Google position promises nothing about the AI answer, so you check the AI answers separately.

How do you measure whether AI answers cite you?

By hand, you put four things together: Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools for their own AI features, GA4 for the visits, and a list of questions you ask ChatGPT and Gemini yourself, logged per AI.

  1. In Search Console, open Settings > Search generative AI and check that it says include. Include is the default; exclude means the site gets no impressions or traffic from those features, and Google says the setting isn't used as a ranking signal for the rest of Search. When a client has no AI impressions at all, this is the first place to look.
  2. Open the Generative AI performance report, available worldwide since 31 August 2026. It shows how often links to the site appeared in AI Overviews and AI Mode, and on which pages, per country, device or date. Clicks aren't in it: they stay in the normal Performance report under the Web search type, which the Search Console guide walks through. No report at all usually means the site hasn't had enough impressions yet.
  3. In Bing Webmaster Tools, open AI Performance, in public preview since February 2026. It shows how often Copilot and Bing's AI summaries cited the site, which URLs, and the grounding queries behind them. It reports citations only, and Microsoft says the data is a sample.
  4. In GA4, open Acquisition > Traffic acquisition, pick Session source in the dimension drop-down and look for chatgpt.com, gemini.google.com, perplexity.ai and copilot.microsoft.com. Clicks from AI Overviews and AI Mode never get a source of their own, because Google sends no separate referrer for them; they land in google / organic with the rest. The GA4 guide covers the report itself.
  5. Write down the questions the client's customers ask: about the service, the comparisons they make, the problem the client solves for them. Phrase each one the way a customer would ask an AI. Put every question to ChatGPT and to Gemini with your own history switched off, because ChatGPT may use saved memories when it rewrites a search. Log per question and per AI whether the site was linked, named without a link, or left out, and who was named instead. A few dozen questions is a fair start for one client.

I took every question the business sites in my account track, 95 on 17 sites, and read a month of answers: 173 of them, 95 from ChatGPT and 78 from Gemini, between 20 October and 17 November 2026. The site behind the question was linked in 21 answers (12%). ChatGPT linked it 9 times out of 95, Gemini 12 times out of 78. It was named without a link in about 10 answers (about 6%), which I counted by hand, and left out of about 141, about 81%. That's one month, mostly Dutch small businesses, with questions the owners picked themselves.

The two AIs rarely agreed. Of the 78 questions both answered, 3 linked the site from both AIs, 14 from one and 61 from neither. A link doesn't stay put either: since late August, 13 question-and-AI pairs in my account linked the site at least once, and only one of them linked it every time. SparkToro measured the same restlessness with brand lists and put the chance that two answers give the same list at less than 1 in 100.

That is why linked and named without a link are two separate counts, kept per AI, over many questions.

One answer from ChatGPT tells you nothing. Ask the same question tomorrow and you get other sources. I look at the share of questions where a client is a source, per AI, once a month with the report.

By hand, step 5 is a few dozen questions times two AIs, for every client. In MarketingTracer's AI Insights you add each client's questions per site, written as a customer would ask an AI. The AI answers tab then shows per question whether ChatGPT and Gemini cite the site and in which place among the sources, name it without a link or leave it out, and who they mentioned instead.

A table of eight questions an agency's customers ask, with per question whether ChatGPT and Gemini cite the agency's site, mention it, or leave it out, and which sites they mention instead

Demo account, sample data.

What can you do to get cited?

Make sure every AI can reach and use the page, write the page that answers the customer's question, and keep the business's name and listings right. Most of the AEO tactics sold on top of that you can skip. Per client site, these are the checks:

  • The search bots get in. Check every bot from the table in robots.txt and in the firewall or CDN, because a firewall can block a bot that robots.txt lets in. OpenAI recommends allowing OAI-SearchBot in robots.txt and allowing its published IP ranges. The Googlebot article shows how to check it.
  • Indexed, with a snippet. A nosnippet or max-snippet:0 on the page limits how it can appear in Google's AI features. Check URL inspection in Search Console and the page's robots meta tag.
  • Search generative AI on include. Step 1 above, once per client property.
  • A page that answers the question in its first lines. Google's guide expects content that people find unique and useful to do more for a site in AI search, in the long run, than any other tip it gives. Put the client's question list next to the site and mark each question that no page answers.
  • The business name and listings in order. With ChatGPT's Maps links, the Google Business Profile carries the name as much as the site does. Check the profile and the directories the client is listed in for the same name and address, and a link to the right site.
  • Mentions elsewhere that are real. Reviews and press, and partners or suppliers who write about the client. Google's guide warns that seeking inauthentic "mentions" across the web "isn't as helpful as it might seem", so a bought list of mentions is money gone.

Now what you can skip. llms.txt is first in line. Google Search ignores it, so it will "neither harm nor help" a site there, and on 137,210 domains Ahrefs found that 97% of the llms.txt files received no traffic at all in May 2026.

Chopping text into small chunks and adding special schema don't help either. Google's guide says there's "no requirement to break your content into tiny pieces" and "no special schema.org markup you need to add". Structured data still earns rich results; it just isn't an AI trick. FAQ markup lost even that when Google stopped showing FAQ rich results on 7 May 2026.

It doesn't win ChatGPT citations either. In SE Ranking's 2025 study of 129,000 domains, pages with FAQ schema averaged 3.6 ChatGPT citations against 4.2 for pages without.

A page for every fan-out query is the real trap. Google's guide says that writing them mainly to manipulate rankings or AI answers in Google Search breaks its scaled content abuse policy, and that is how a site turns into a content farm.

The study most AEO articles quote is the GEO paper: adding sources, quotes and statistics to a text raised its visibility by up to 40% in a test engine the researchers built on top of Google results. It says something about how a page does once it's among the sources, and nothing about getting there.

Microsoft gives different advice for AI assistants like its Copilot: question-and-answer pairs and schema, in "modular layouts". Google's 2026 guide puts the weight elsewhere. Each speaks for its own engine.

Does AEO bring traffic, and what goes in the client report?

A little, and most of it from ChatGPT. Across 101,574 sites in SE Ranking's 2026 traffic study, AI platforms sent 0.32% of all traffic, and ChatGPT 74.78% of that. On the 15 sites in my account that aren't mine, AI assistants sent 320 of 30,041 sessions in October 2026, about 1%, and ChatGPT sent 307 of them. You see those visits in GA4 by source, as in step 4.

Google's AI summaries cost clicks. Pew Research followed 900 US adults in March 2025: they clicked a result in 8% of visits with an AI summary against 15% without one, and a link inside the summary in 1%.

Being in the summary is still worth more than being left out of it. Seer Interactive found that brands cited in an AI Overview got 120% more organic clicks per impression than when they weren't cited.

When a client asks whether they show up in ChatGPT, I don't send a score. I show the questions their customers ask, who gets named instead of them, and which page we're going to improve next month.

The numbers go underneath, as the proof: per AI, the share of the tracked questions where the client is a source, which of the client's pages get cited, and the visits from AI to those pages. A client reads that in a minute and knows whether it's moving and what happens next.

In MarketingTracer, the AI traffic tab of AI Insights lists the visits from AI per landing page and per assistant, with "Source in prompts" next to each page: in how many of the questions you track that page is a source. AI Insights can also go into the client report as a section (the overview, the competitors or the AI traffic, for the report's month), and you build, check and send that report yourself. Visitors from Google's AI Overviews can't be told apart there either, because Google counts them as regular search traffic.

More about AI search

  • Content farm: when pages published in bulk to catch search traffic turn into what Google calls scaled content abuse, whether a person or a model writes them.
  • AI writing patterns: the habits of unedited chatbot copy, and how to spot them.

Keep reading

Free 14-day trial

MarketingTracer smart A.I. tool shows you what you need to rank. Then we'll help you get it done.

  • No credit card required
  • No installation needed
  • No strings attached
Start your 14-day trial